Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Sarah Wickerham
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Sarah Wickerham

Wickerham Insurance Agency, Inc.

833 Adair Ave
Zanesville, OH 43701

On the corner of Hazel and Adair Avenues

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call us 24 hours a day!

Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting


833 Adair Ave
Zanesville, OH 43701



We do things differently here at Wickerham Insurance Agency, Inc. We help our policyholders make GREAT decisions every day! What is most important to you? If you aren't sure, or haven't had an insurance professional help you determine your needs, we are here to help! Our recommendations are based on YOU and your situation. Every policyholder deserves the personalized, hands on service that we provide. We love the communities we serve and are honored to be a part of Southeastern Ohio.

Our team is experienced in Auto, Home, Life, Health and Business insurance. Call us for a FREE, no obligation quote that is based on your needs. We live where you live. We serve families in Muskingum, Licking, Perry, Guernsey, and surrounding counties and look forward to meeting you soon! If relocating to Ohio, we are your team! We support Zanesville, Nashport, Dresden, New Concord, Frazeysburg or Duncan Falls, we are here to help. We are available 24/7 via email or by phone. We can also meet you in person, by phone, in a virtual meeting. Stop by and see us today!

Sarah is a member of the North Terrace Church of Christ and an active supporter of several local charitable organizations, including Big Brothers Big Sisters and Eastside Community Ministry. Sarah has been a resident of Muskingum County since 2010, choosing to raise her 6 children with her husband Jeff in the community they are dedicated to.

  • Summer is upon us. We are here to help protect your motorcycle, boat, RV, ATV, and all those vehicles you use for summertime travel fun! 🚤

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Tips for driving safely in the rain

Driving in the rain doesn't have to be stressful and it's not good to drive as if it were warm and dry. Follow these safety tips to help you when driving in the rain.

The Real Consequences of Drunk Driving

What's at stake if you're caught drunk driving? A lot. These tips help you avoid the dangers of drinking and driving.

It's not the breed — any dog can bite

Dog bites can happen regardless of the breed, so use caution around canines.

View More Articles

Our mission is to support each customer in a way that speaks to our family values of respect, dignity and care while providing insurance and financial services that will help to secure and improve the way of life for them and their loved ones. We help customers make GREAT decisions for the family and their future. We care for and live in the communities we serve!

Our licensed, well-trailed team is ready to help! Together, we have over 50 years of experience helping policyholders. Our entire team will work to help you understand your insurance needs while respecting your budget. We are here for you when you need us!

Mary Touvell State Farm Agent Team Member

Mary Touvell

Multiple Line Representative

Mary is our longest-tenured multiple-line representative, having service State Farm Policyholders since 2008. She enjoys helping with home, auto and business insurance. She also has a passion for helping policyholders protect their families with life insurance and paycheck protection plans.

Mary is a mom of 2 and "Mimi" to 4 adorable grandchildren. She also has a drive for fitness and exercise!

Mikayla Nash State Farm Agent Team Member

Mikayla Nash

Multiple Line Representative

Mikayla joined our team in the summer of 2022 after obtaining her Property and Casualty license. Her role first started as our office manager, where she became our resident service leader for claims, billing and policy questions. She most recently transitioned to a role of multiple line representative where she serves policyholders through new business appointments, coverage reviews and liability protection updates.

Mikayla is an active member of North Terrace Church of Christ, where her husband is the Connections Minister. She also loves snuggling her cats whenever she can!

Jolene Davis State Farm Agent Team Member

Jolene Davis

Multiple Line Representative

Jolene is originally from the Pocono Mountains in PA, but has lived all over the as part of her military career before joining Sarah Wickerham State Farm in 2023. She served seven years in the US Coast Guard as a Health Services Technician. Her duty stations included Oak Island, NC, Oahu Hi, Elizabeth City NC, as well as a few more with her spouse who also served. She has an associates degree in Architectural Design & Technology and a Bachelors degree in Environmental Studies. Upon joining our team, she earned both her Ohio Property/Casualty and Life/Health licenses, now serving as a multiple line representative.

Jolene is the mother of 4 beautiful girls and a true animal lover. She enjoys camping with her family, reading, hiking and outdoor adventures as well as cooking and baking with her girls.

Reagan Dygert State Farm Agent Team Member

Reagan Dygert

Office Manager

Reagan is our Office Manager as of September 2023 and has enjoyed learning from the team as a newly licensed property and casualty representative. She takes the lead on assisting customers to recover from the unexpected during a claim. She is also the first face to greet you on most day of the week.

She has lived in Zanesville since 2010 and is a graduate of Maysville High School. She has served the community as a preschool and elementary educator until making her career change to join our team.

In her personal life, she is a wife and mom to a sweet two-year-old boy and one of her personal passions is community theater -- she frequently performs and volunteers with Zanesville Community Theater as well as The Renner.

Bailey Kelley State Farm Agent Team Member

Bailey Kelley

Customer Service Representative

Bailey joined our team in the summer of 2023 after completing her associates degree and earning her state of Ohio Property and Casualty license. She is a member of our customer service team and dedicated to providing the remarkable service that our policyholders deserve.

Bailey comes from a State Farm family, with both of her parents having served with the organization for many years. She loves animals and philosophy as well as solving brain teasers. Bailey also enjoys reading, watching movies and baking in her free time.

Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.