Office Hours
Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Annuities
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Sarah Wickerham
Wickerham Insurance Agency, Inc.
Office Hours
Address
Zanesville, OH 43701
On the corner of Hazel and Adair Avenues
Office Hours
Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Annuities
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Office Info
Office Info
Office Hours
Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting
Location Details
- Parking: Behind the building
-
Phone
(740) 454-3276 -
Fax
(740) 454-7085
Languages
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Annuities
Office Info
Office Info
Office Hours
Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting
Location Details
- Parking: Behind the building
-
Phone
(740) 454-3276 -
Fax
(740) 454-7085
Languages
Simple Insights®
Should I buy or lease a car?
Should I buy or lease a car?
Thinking about leasing vs buying a car? There are several pros and cons for each option to consider before you decide which works best for you.
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.
How to recognize drowning signs
How to recognize drowning signs
The signs of drowning may surprise you. Here's how to recognize the common signs and tips for drowning prevention.
Social Media
Viewing team member 1 of 6
Mary Touvell
Multiple Line Representative
License #758507
Mary is our longest-tenured multiple-line representative, having service State Farm Policyholders since 2008. She enjoys helping with home, auto and business insurance. She also has a passion for helping policyholders protect their families with life insurance and paycheck protection plans.
Mary is a mom of 2 and "Mimi" to 4 adorable grandchildren. She also has a drive for fitness and exercise!
Viewing team member 2 of 6
Mikayla Nash
Multiple Line Representative
License #1447620
Mikayla joined our team in the summer of 2022 after obtaining her Property and Casualty license. Her role first started as our office manager, where she became our resident service leader for claims, billing and policy questions. She most recently transitioned to a role of multiple line representative where she serves policyholders through new business appointments, coverage reviews and liability protection updates.
Mikayla is an active member of North Terrace Church of Christ, where her husband is the Connections Minister. She also loves snuggling her cats whenever she can!
Viewing team member 3 of 6
Reagan Dygert
Office Manager
License #1533747
Reagan is our Office Manager as of September 2023 and has enjoyed learning from the team as a newly licensed property and casualty representative. She takes the lead on assisting customers to recover from the unexpected during a claim. She is also the first face to greet you on most day of the week.
She has lived in Zanesville since 2010 and is a graduate of Maysville High School. She has served the community as a preschool and elementary educator until making her career change to join our team.
In her personal life, she is a wife and mom to a sweet two-year-old boy and one of her personal passions is community theater -- she frequently performs and volunteers with Zanesville Community Theater as well as The Renner.
Viewing team member 4 of 6
Bailey Kelley
Customer Service Representative
License #1531644
Bailey joined our team in the summer of 2023 after completing her associates degree and earning her state of Ohio Property and Casualty license. She is a member of our customer service team and dedicated to providing the remarkable service that our policyholders deserve.
Bailey comes from a State Farm family, with both of her parents having served with the organization for many years. She loves animals and philosophy as well as solving brain teasers. Bailey also enjoys reading, watching movies and baking in her free time.
Viewing team member 5 of 6
Erin McCoy
Multiple Line Representative
License #1604320
With a prior teaching history, Erin joins our team ready to help policyholders understand their coverage needs and options. She was born and raised in Muskingum County and has deep ties to our community. She is licensed in Life, Health, Auto, Fire and Business insurance.
Viewing team member 6 of 6
Marlie Baker
Marketing Service Assistant
Marlie joined our team in 2025 as a part-time marketing assistant. Her primary role is contacting policyholders to schedule annual review appointments.
While not working at our office, Marlie is successfully tackling a heaving course load in high school. She is also a member of the Tri-Valley Girls Varsity Soccer team. In her limited spare time, she enjoys spending time with friends and family, cooking and watching "Outer Banks."
Zanesville, OH Full Time